Skip to Main Content

SW 200/SW 201: Introduction to Social Work and Social Welfare: Literature Review and Evaluation

This guide was created to support Dr. Kelley's SW 200 and SW 201.

How to Evaluate a Book or Article

Why do we evaluate books or articles?

  • Check if the source is relevant for our research topic
  • Help build our suggested intervention

Qualities to look for

Always keep in mind your research interest. How does this article/book relate to your topic?

Look for qualities like:

  • What is their question/hypothesis? What are they researching?
  • Who is being researched? Age-group? Ethnicity? Gender? Is anyone left out?
  • Where is the research happening? In the USA? In a hospital?
  • What is their practice strategy or intervention? What are the researchers trying out to see if it helps the group they're studying?
  • How are they measuring to see if the intervention worked? Are they doing interviews? Surveys?
  • What was the outcome of their study?

 

Active Reading

Active reading has these goals:

  • You can articulate the article's main ideas.
  • You can evaluate the material's usefulness for your project.
  • You can use the material in your project (if you decided it was useful).

At any point, if you realize that the article isn't useful for your project, drop that article and move on to the next one

You can active read with the SQ3R method. At each step, you will need to write. You can write physically on a printed copy, or you can annotate a pdf through software like Zotero

This is a graph showing the SQ3R method: survey, question, read, recite, and review.

  • Survey - Where is this article going?
    • Read the title and abstract
    • Read topic and subtopic headings and sentences
    • Try to identify the main idea or thesis of the article
    • Write these notes on the article.
  • Questions - What do I want to find out?
    • ​​​​​​​Create a question for each heading a subheading.
    • Mark any words/terms you don't know.
    • Mark any paragraphs that are confusing and try to explain why they are confusing.
    • Ask any other questions that come to mind.
    • Write these notes on the article.
  • Read - Can I answer my questions?
    • Read the article slowly and carefully.
    • Answer any of the questions that you asked earlier.
    • Look up definitions for words/phrases you didn't know.
    • Mark important ideas, paraphrase these ideas, and write why they are important.
    • Write these notes on the article.
  • Recall - What did I take away from this article?
    • On your own, try to remember the major ideas from the article.
    • If thinking about the whole article is too hard, then you can first break it down into chunks.
    • Write these notes on the article.
  • Review - Can I explain the main idea of this article to someone who hasn't read it?
    • Look at your previous questions, answers, and notes.
    • Check if what you wrote in the Recall step really matches the article's content.
    • Try to explain the article to another person, a pet, or an imaginary audience.

Identifying Articles Video

Evaluating Academic Book Quality

Books should be evaluated for academic quality.

  • Authorship - Book authors should have expertise and authority in the subject. This can be shown by:
    • A doctoral degree in the discipline. Most authors you can search online to see their educational background.
    • An association with an educational institution like a University or a research organization.
  • Publisher - An academic publisher is not necessary, but it is a good sign.
  • Proof of research - There should be a list of sources the author used to write their work. They might be listed at the end of each chapter, in footnotes, or at the end of the entire book.
  • Reviews - A scholarly book may have book reviews published in academic journals. You can find book reviews by searching databases like Academic Search Complete with the book's title.