Skip to Main Content

AN 454: Anthropological Theory: Evaluating Articles

This guide is designed to support AN 454 in Fall 2024.

Why Evaluate Articles?

Before you use an article (or any other resource) in your research, you should evaluate the article's quality and appropriateness for your assignment.

Why Care About Peer-Review?

Peer-reviewed articles (also known as "refereed articles") have gone through the peer review process prior to publication.

The author's expert peers evaluate the quality of the article and the article's research. The publisher publishes the article only after the article has been approved by the expert reviewers.

If an article is peer-reviewed, you can be more confident in the article's quality.

How Can I Tell if an Article is Peer-Reviewed?

There are a few different ways to check if an article is peer-reviewed. Each journal may represent the peer-review process differently.

If you search for articles in a database like Academic Search Complete, you might have the option to filter to show only peer-reviewed articles. In Academic Search Complete, this option is in the Advanced Search screen. There is a checkbox to filter to show only peer-reviewed items.

If you use a different database, or no database at all, to find articles, you will have to do the investigating yourself.

Some publisher website layouts will have peer-review process timestamps like this:

Screenshot of a Publication History timeline with dates for the peer-review process.

Sometimes, only the article's PDF will have these timestamps.

What Kind of Article did I Find?

The same journal can publish different types of articles. These article types might not all go through peer review (be refereed).

Not all publishers label their article types! Be on the lookout to check what type of article you have accessed!

Look at different article types with me in this Article Types Video.

Book Review

Book Review Example.

  • Book reviews often start with a citation of the book being reviewed. This might include a price.
  • Book reviews are usually short.
  • Book reviews focus on the quality of one book.
  • Book reviews do not include original research.

Editorial

Editorial Example.

  • Editorials may be labeled as an editorial on the publisher's website.
  • Editorials may be long or short.
  • Editorials focus on the journal, journal issue, or another article published in the journal.
  • Editorials are written by editors.
  • Editorials do not include original research.

Opinion

Opinion Example.

  • Opinion pieces may be labeled as "Opinion" or "Commentary" on the publisher's page.
  • Opinion pieces may be long or short.
  • Opinion pieces focus on a topic adjacent to actual research. They might discuss another published article, a community's attitude towards a research topic, or questions about a discipline practice.
  • Opinion pieces likely have a references list and in-text citations.
  • Opinion pieces should not include original research.